logo      welcometoentrepreneurcountrylogo
Log in using Facebook Forgot login?Register
News & Features Business Know-How Does the Pimlico Plumbers pay experiment work?

Does the Pimlico Plumbers pay experiment work? Featured

Written by Kelly Dolan on Friday, 13 July 2012 11:04
Rate this item
(0 votes)
This week, it was by duty and by fascination that I tuned in to Channel 4 to watch Show Me Your Money, a documentary featuring Pimlico Plumbers owner and Entrepreneur Country cover star Charlie Mullins asking his employees to expose their wage packets to each other.

The programme launched with Charlie calling his minions into a meeting, and he pulled no punches by outrightly requesting that staff take part in writing their salaries on a board for the rest of the team to see.

Unrest ensued, bitterness was rife and to top it off Mullins left employees to sort it out amongst themselves - from call centre staff to canteen workers, all the way up to body workers and the plumbers themselves. The proposition was that instead of expecting him to raise salaries, staff were to evenly distribute their wage packets as a responsibility to their team.

Call centre workers on £18,000 were furious that a new recruit was earning £3,000 more a year. Mechanic Mark resented his co-worker earning £9,000 more despite having exactly the same position. Canteen worker Tina's measly income of £14,500 left her with only £5 a week in spare cash. Yet, the plumbers came out on trump, with some earning £150,000 a year.

So what was the solution? In an attempt to restore justice, call workers pleaded with plumbers to donate £3 a week of their earnings to bump up their £18,000 salaries, which was met with laughter and accusations of "go and find another job if you're not happy, nobodies forcing you to work here." Scott Mullins, Charlie's son and call centre manager, earns £120,000, with his only comment being "Dad's company- get off my case!" Equally, PR Director Karl refused to give up £1,000 of his £56,000 salary to donate to canteen worker Tina, instead asking for a pay rise increase to £75,000 (which Charlie scoffs at, saying "Who does he think he is, Max bleedin' Clifford?")

Overall, the documentary raises so many questions on the taboo of discussing wage packets and the dangers of running an informal pay scheme that, in Charlie's words, is based on 'You look like you're working hard, have a few more quid. You look like a lazy bastard, we take a few quid off ya'."  There was also this overriding theme that people should feel grateful for any job at all, with top earning plumber 'Lurch' telling a call centre worker she should stop complaining about the cost of her rent and be grateful that she has a roof over her head, which of course was met with malice.

Hoiwever, the programme concluded with a happy workforce and a teary-eyed Charlie who was clearly proud of the results shown not by senior management, but by his team of mechanics in the garage. Instead of arguing over losing their wages, the team worked out that they could make savings across their supply chain without losing quality, using the money reaped back to fund the whole team gaining the pay rise they requested, with amounts met with Charlie's own money.

I'd recommend business owners in particular to watch the programme here if you want to see a great case study on analysing those working for you and how to inevitably gain a happier workforce. The mechanics initiative towards the end also sheds light on a recent trend encouraging businesses to give workers in lower positions projects to showcase their skills, eeking out the real talent within the company. However, I question the notion that any company can have a truly happy workforce if salaries are exposed. After all, it is usually those working on the ground level that are keeping the business afloat and suffer silently, while top earning execs reap the rewards and sit in comfortable private offices. Can there ever be an equlibrium whereby employees accept that rates of pay aren't always based on how hard you work?

Last modified on Friday, 13 July 2012 12:18
Kelly Dolan

Kelly Dolan

Kelly Dolan joined Entrepreneur Country in January 2012 as Head of Content. Her current responsibilities include managing Entrepreneur Country’s host of media platforms, including creating a weekly newsletter for investors and entrepreneurs, designing and editing a monthly digital magazine as well as managing an inventory of 200 leading entrepreneurial contributors, who share their business insights with Entrepreneur Country readers through it’s various communication channels. Kelly has also worked on account management, business development and sales, as well as strengthened engagement and increased the population of the Entrepreneur Country community.

Prior to joining Entrepreneur Country Kelly worked as a freelance journalist for Bauer Media on a range of men’s and women’s titles during crucial periods of digital transformation. Kelly also speaks at young entrepreneurial programmes, workshops and business schools, as well as sits on panels for industry events.

Website: www.entrepreneurcountry.com

comments  

 
0 # Neil McClure 2012-07-22 20:15
Reading the review of this programme I was struck by the use of the word minions!
Is that current entrepreneurial speak?
Reply | Reply with quote | Quote
 
 
0 # Tom Hartley 2012-07-24 14:46
thoughtful piece, liked that questions were raised, might just have to watch the programme
Reply | Reply with quote | Quote
 

Add comment


Security code
Refresh

Latest Comments

Welcome to Entrepreneur Country

Community Coffee Lounge

Welcome to the Entrepreneur Country Coffee Lounge.

coffee_lounge

With a host of viral videos, games, cartoons and puzzles, its your time to relax.

Entrepreneur Country

Related Media

Facebook/Twitter

EC Tweets

Loading...

Last 4 tweets from EnCountry:

Poll

Should Britain be part of the European Union?

Yes - 69.2%
No - 30.8%

Total votes: 78
The voting for this poll has ended on: 23 Feb 2013 - 14:44